Taylor Cole and Charles Michael Davis bring wonderful chemistry to a holiday romance that reminds us love isn't something we can plan, predict, or win.
Courtesy of Hallmark Media
Written by Christopher L. Antie
Hallmark's Our Holiday Playbook embraces this familiar but surprisingly relatable experience, delivering an entertaining Christmas romance that explores the differences between family expectations, competitive traditions, and finding happiness on our own terms.
Starring Taylor Cole as Lexi Bell and Charles Michael Davis as Eddie, the film introduces two individuals who find themselves navigating the complicated traditions of their respective families. Lexi returns home for Christmas and encounters the annual Bell Bowl, a fiercely competitive flag football game fueled by a longstanding rivalry between her father and uncle. When her family's chances of winning become increasingly uncertain, she turns to Eddie, a former football star turned teacher, for help. Their arrangement is simple enough. Eddie will pretend to be Lexi's boyfriend and join her family's football team, while Lexi will help him prepare for his own family's annual baking competition against his brother.
The fake-dating premise is certainly nothing new to romantic comedies, particularly those associated with Hallmark. However, what makes Our Holiday Playbook successful is its willingness to allow the relationship to develop naturally rather than immediately forcing the characters toward an expected romantic destination.
Cole delivers a convincing and well-balanced performance as Lexi. She captures the personality of a determined woman whose decisions are influenced by family expectations while quietly navigating her own feelings. Her performance is so natural that, at times, it becomes difficult to distinguish whether her character is simply maintaining the arrangement or beginning to recognize something genuine.
Davis is equally impressive as Eddie, bringing a calm, confident, and emotionally balanced presence to the screen. Rather than exaggerating his character's charm or relying on dramatic dialogue, Davis allows Eddie's personality to emerge through his subtle expressions, humor, and interactions.
Together, Cole and Davis create wonderful chemistry. Their conversations, facial expressions, and natural interactions establish a believable connection that strengthens as the story progresses. There is a comfortable quality to their performances, as though the characters have known each other long enough to understand more than they are prepared to acknowledge.
For Will and me, the experience of allowing a relationship to develop while keeping certain feelings and beliefs private is something we understand. Our circumstances were different from those portrayed in the film, but the emotional connection felt familiar. Sometimes two people begin as friends, carrying personal reasons for not expressing everything they feel. Over time, those reasons can become less important than the relationship itself.
Love does not always begin with a declaration or a carefully planned romantic moment. Sometimes it grows through friendship, understanding, and the realization that someone has become an important part of your life.
Interestingly, research suggests that this progression is more common than many might expect.
A 2021 study published in Social Psychological and Personality Science, titled The Friends-to-Lovers Pathway to Romance: Prevalent, Preferred, and Overlooked by Science, examined seven samples involving 1,897 participants. Researchers found that approximately two-thirds reported that their current or previous romantic relationships began as friendships.
Although the research did not examine pretend relationships becoming genuine, it supports an important observation: romantic connections frequently develop from existing friendships rather than beginning with an immediate intention to fall in love.
That distinction gives Our Holiday Playbook a sense of authenticity. Lexi and Eddie's arrangement may be fictional, but the emotions that gradually develop around it are recognizable.
Where the film becomes somewhat less convincing is in its treatment of family competition.
The Bell Bowl introduces an entertaining and unusual Christmas tradition, especially through the rivalry between Lexi's father and uncle. Yet the competitive atmosphere occasionally feels excessive, raising an interesting question about the purpose of holiday traditions.
Christmas gatherings should ideally encourage families to spend meaningful time together. When winning becomes the primary objective, some participants may feel excluded, and the excitement of competition can begin to overshadow the relationships those traditions were intended to strengthen.
The baking competition involving Eddie and his brother presents a similar challenge. Although the rivalry contributes to the film's humor and storyline, we would have appreciated greater emotional development between the brothers. Their competitive relationship had the potential to reveal more about their personal histories and the importance of maintaining family connections.
Combining two very different competitions creates an interesting narrative structure, but it occasionally makes the screenplay feel uneven. Certain family disagreements could have carried greater emotional weight, while some moments rely on the familiar conventions of a traditional Hallmark romance.
The supporting cast helps provide balance. The mothers bring particularly enjoyable personalities to the family gatherings, contributing warmth and humor that make the interactions feel more natural. The younger family member also adds a grounded perspective, reminding viewers that family relationships involve more than the disagreements and ambitions of the adults.
Production quality is another strength. The film's cinematography, decorations, costumes, music, and editing create an appealing Christmas atmosphere. The football and baking sequences are visually engaging, and the overall pacing allows the central relationship to develop without feeling unnecessarily rushed.
Director Terry Ingram presents the holiday gatherings with a polished visual style that supports the film's cheerful atmosphere.
Nevertheless, while the romantic chemistry feels authentic, the screenplay does not always deliver the same emotional depth through its supporting relationships. Greater vulnerability, stronger consequences surrounding the family disagreements, and more natural dialogue in certain scenes could have created a richer experience.
The difference is important because Our Holiday Playbook has a meaningful message beneath its festive competition.
Happiness is not something we should have to compete for, nor should love depend entirely on meeting the expectations of the people around us.
Sometimes we become so focused on making others happy that we forget to consider what genuinely brings happiness into our own lives.
Family traditions can be valuable, but their greatest purpose should be strengthening relationships rather than determining who wins and who loses.
Through Lexi and Eddie, the film reminds us that understanding another person requires more than sharing a few enjoyable experiences. It involves recognizing their strengths, witnessing their difficulties, and appreciating who they are beyond the expectations placed upon them.
Chris & Will give Hallmark's Our Holiday Playbook 9 out of 10 smiles.
The film earns its rating through the excellent performances of Taylor Cole and Charles Michael Davis, their wonderfully natural chemistry, appealing production, and a romantic storyline that develops with genuine charm.
Although the screenplay could have benefited from more emotional depth and a more natural balance between the family competitions and personal relationships, the film succeeds in delivering a meaningful and entertaining Christmas experience.
For viewers who enjoy romantic comedies, family-centered storytelling, and stories about unexpected love, Our Holiday Playbook is a worthwhile addition to Hallmark's Countdown to Christmas lineup.
Its greatest lesson is not about football, baking, or winning a family competition. It is about recognizing the value of a relationship that develops without a carefully constructed plan.
After all, the most meaningful victories in life are not always celebrated with trophies. Sometimes they are found in the people who remain beside us, the connections we never anticipated, and the love we eventually allow ourselves to recognize.
Because happiness isn't something we win. It's something we discover, appreciate, and choose to build together.
Our Holiday Playbook premieres Friday, November 20, 2026, at 8/7c on Hallmark Channel and streams the following day on Hallmark+.
Research reference: Stinson, D. A., Cameron, J. J., and Hoplock, L. B. (2021). The Friends-to-Lovers Pathway to Romance: Prevalent, Preferred, and Overlooked by Science. Social Psychological and Personality Science.
Source: ChrisWill Media
About the Authors: Christopher L. Antie and William Antie are podcast journalists and media personalities covering entertainment, travel, culture, events, and stories from across a wide range of industries. Together, they bring a conversational and experience-driven approach to the stories they share. Follow more from Chris & Will through their podcast, What About Our Life?, on iHeartRadio and at chrisandwill.com.
